← Back to the journal

Maté vs. Coffee: Two Classics, Two Ways to Begin

Materos Unidos — Maté vs. Coffee cover

5 MIN READ · MATÉ VS. SERIES

On origin, flavour, and the surprising versatility of yerba maté.

Coffee has its familiar places: the corner café, the kitchen counter, the morning espresso. Yerba maté belongs to another tradition, rooted in South America and often shared from a single gourd.

Both reward attention to origin and preparation. And they meet in an unexpected place: the roast.

01. From Fruit to Leaf

Coffee is made from the roasted seeds of coffee cherries. Yerba maté comes from the leaves of Ilex paraguariensis, a South American tree with a longstanding place in Guaraní culture.

Coffee begins as a fruit: the familiar bean is its seed.
Coffee begins as a fruit: the familiar bean is its seed.

Their histories are distinct. What they share is a place in daily life that goes well beyond the beverage itself.

A South American landscape, and a ritual with deep regional roots.
A South American landscape, and a ritual with deep regional roots.

02. In the Cup

Coffee may be bright and fruity or deep with notes of chocolate, caramel and nuts. Its origin, roast and extraction shape the result.

In coffee, roast and extraction each leave their mark on the cup.
In coffee, roast and extraction each leave their mark on the cup.

Traditional, untoasted maté tends toward herbal, earthy and woody notes, with a characteristic bitterness. Drying and ageing influence its character; some yerbas are smoky, while others are deliberately unsmoked.

03. One Leaf, Many Expressions

Chimarrão, popular in southern Brazil, is typically vivid green, finely milled and consumed without extended ageing. It is served hot in a cuia, through a metal bomba.

Argentine, Paraguayan and Uruguayan-style yerbas are commonly aged, though producers vary. Argentine blends often include stems; Uruguayan cuts are generally finer, with little stem; Paraguayan styles may be robust and sometimes smoky.1

Tereré takes a colder path. Closely associated with Paraguay, it is prepared with cold water, frequently ice and herbs. Traditional Paraguayan tereré practices were recognized by UNESCO in 2020.2

Three expressions of maté: aged-style yerba, cold tereré and vivid-green chimarrão.
Three expressions of maté: aged-style yerba, cold tereré and vivid-green chimarrão.

Fresh, aged, cold or toasted: maté has no single expression.

04. The Unexpected Roast

Toasting yerba maté can draw out warmer notes reminiscent of roasted grains, cocoa, nuts—and sometimes coffee. No coffee beans are required.3

We explored that connection ourselves: we toasted Mate Suelto, filled an espresso portafilter and extracted the infusion into a porcelain cup. These photographs follow the experiment from leaf to finished drink.

Our Mate Suelto, toasted for this experiment.
Our Mate Suelto, toasted for this experiment.
Toasted maté extracted through an espresso machine.
Toasted maté extracted through an espresso machine.
The finished infusion, made without coffee beans.
The finished infusion, made without coffee beans.

This was an experiment, not a product change. Our Mate Suelto is sold untoasted; the roasting was done specifically for this tasting.

05. More Than Caffeine

Coffee and maté share a familiar ingredient: caffeine. Studies commonly report around 10–20 mg per gram of dried yerba maté. Coffee varies by bean, too: often around 12 mg per gram in roasted Arabica and 22 mg in Robusta. These figures describe the dry leaf or bean, not the finished drink. How much reaches the cup depends on the preparation.4, 6

But there is more to the leaf. Yerba maté also contains theobromine, a compound found in cocoa, along with very small—and sometimes undetectable—amounts of theophylline and a range of naturally occurring polyphenols. They are part of maté's botanical character, not a promise that its caffeine is somehow different.4

The experience also depends on the ritual. Rather than brewing just once, traditional maté is enjoyed through successive pours over the same leaves. The flavour changes, and caffeine continues to be extracted with each refill.5

Different ingredients, different preparations, and a pleasure worth discovering beyond the numbers.

06. A Cup, a Circle

Coffee has its café culture. Maté has the ronda: the shared vessel, the person who serves it, and the conversations that unfold between rounds. Both can be enjoyed alone or in company; each brings its own customs to the table.

Maté alongside the asado: part of the everyday art of gathering.
Maté alongside the asado: part of the everyday art of gathering.

Our Point of View

At Materos Unidos, we approach maté as we would fine coffee or wine: through provenance, process and palate.

Our Mate Suelto comes from Paraná, Brazil. Air-dried without smoke and aged for nearly seven years, it earned a Gran Oro distinction at the 2026 Mundial de la Yerba Mate.

Marko in Montréal, with Mate Suelto and a traditional maté.
Marko in Montréal, with Mate Suelto and a traditional maté.
Serge, sharing the same ritual across borders.
Serge, sharing the same ritual across borders.

Maté does not need to replace coffee to merit a place beside it. Its range—from green chimarrão to cold tereré and toasted infusions—makes the case on its own.

Two classics. No need to choose sides.

Many places. One maté.

Discover Mate Suelto — Materos Unidos.

REFERENCES & FURTHER READING
  1. Instituto Nacional de la Yerba Mate and Royal Society of Chemistry — processing and regional cuts.
  2. UNESCO — Paraguay tereré traditions, 2020.
  3. ACS Food Science & Technology — toasted yerba maté.
  4. Yerba Mate—A Long but Current History, Nutrients (2021) — caffeine and naturally occurring compounds in yerba maté.
  5. Fragale et al., Beverages (2026) — caffeine extracted across successive traditional maté servings.
  6. IARC, Coffee — reference caffeine levels in roasted Arabica and Robusta beans.
← Maté vs. Matcha: Taste, Caffeine & Ritual ComparedBefore the Brand, There Was Time →